Simulation of peace talks by Israeli,
Palestinian children productive
On a sunny afternoon in central Israel, tens of Israeli, Palestinian students filled a small library and engaged in a passionate debate in a simulation of peace talks between Israel and Palestine.
On a sunny afternoon in central Israel, tens of Israeli, Palestinian students filled a small library and engaged in a passionate debate in a simulation of peace talks between Israel and Palestine.
Arabic, English
and Hebrew were heard across the room as the teens were on a deadline. They had
24 hours of simulation peace talks and at the end of them their task was to forge
an agreement between Israelis and Palestinians.
Scores of
diplomats and politicians worldwide have yet to find a solution to the
conflict. The kids did. As the clock was ticking, over 70 students of the
Eastern Mediterranean International Boarding School (EMIS), Israelis,
Palestinians and other nationals were divided into three groups. They reached
three different agreements.
"There's no
way a solution is going to be perfect," yelled one student at the other,
as they discussed the most complex issues of the decades old conflict. They dealt with economic cooperation, the
language used in classroom textbooks, who will man checkpoints, the fate of
Palestinian refugees and many other aspects of daily life in the region.
During their
deliberations, the groups handled the most complex of issues and went into
great detail.
"The whole
idea is to show them that there is a democratic instrument to solve disputes by
peaceful means and to show them that in places that leaders are stuck, ordinary
people can bridge the gap and reach agreements," said Dr. Sapir Handelman.
Handelman is an
expert in conflict resolution who facilitated the event hosted by the Charney
Resolution Center. He walked around the
room, helping the teams with mediation when needed.
Although the
daily reality for Palestinians and Israelis is separation and alienation, the
students were trying to achieve a warm peace between the sides. The idea of the
extension of an existing fence between the two enemies was shot down
immediately by some students.
"Nobody
likes a fence or a wall," one of the students said, adding "a fence
is not creating peace, it's just dividing the people." Two of the groups
arrived at the two-state solution, the widely believed solution for the
conflict. The third group of negotiators agreed on a joint Palestinian-Israeli
federation, quite a stretch in today's age of hostility.
For Hagar
Diller, a 17-year-old Israeli who attends EMIS, the simulation is not
necessarily translatable into real life. "There are a lot of things here
that work as a simulation because of the agreements we have between us, because
we need to eventually reach an agreement," she said, noting "but I do
not know how good this will be in real life."
Tzili Charney is
the wife of the late Leon Charney, an American businessman. She founded the
Charney Center in his honor, to commemorate his attempts to facilitate peace
between the two sides. For her, the simulation is actually a mirror of the
reality.
"It's very
realistic," she said when asked if the solutions reached here can work in
the outside world. "They come from homes that are discussing it all the
time, they participate in it, it influences their life all the time," she
added.
Ironically, the
negotiations are held in the school's library, which is also it's bomb shelter.
The fortified windows and special airways do not allow one to escape the
reality of the conflict.
But, for the
youth who participated in the event, it was a chance to learn things about each
other they did not previously know. "A lot of stuff I learned from
Israelis that I didn't know before and there is also a huge amount of stuff
that the Israelis learned from us Palestinians," said Dana Ghoul, a
16-year-oldPalestinian student from East Jerusalem.
In preparation
for the marathon negotiations, the teens received background lessons about the
conflict and were taken on tours to relevant places. Although they share the
same piece of small land, the rivalling sides often feed off images of each
other. The lack of daily interaction between the two leads to stereotypes and
misinformation.
"These
things really, really help me to even see the other side," Diller told
Xinhua. For the foreign students, the event provides a rare opportunity to see
both sides negotiate. It exposes them to the sensitivities and the complexities
of the so far unsolvable conflict.
In the pastoral
setting of the school, amidst green agricultural land, it is difficult to grasp
how close the conflict really is and how intricate any possible solution needs
to be. Someone with a different
perspective may be able to shed different light on the issue.
Wang Xi, a
Chinese student from Ningbo in Zhejiang Province, found the event fascinating.
"Personally, I'm not part of this conflict," he said excitedly,
"but this simulation provides me a lot of opportunity to know people in
the conflict, where on the other hand I can learn a lot of things."
And perhaps that
is exactly what the conflict is missing, creative thinking that will bring
solutions that have not been thought of before. That may be unattainable.
However, the simulation at EMIS provides the opportunity of contact between the
sides which is a rarity in these days.
As long as the
two parties are estranged from each other, the levels of animosity rise and the
ability to sit down and discuss a possible solution decreases dramatically.
The lively
discussion in the room leaves room for optimism. Even if the students do not
become peace-makers, they finish having met the other side and realizing that
dialogue, rather than violence, is possible.
"When
people are involved in heated debate, it means they care for it and this is the
hope," said Dr. Handelman with a smile on his hopeful face. In a deadly
conflict where hope is a word rarely used, that is a huge achievement.
0 Comments
Post a Comment